Demand more

#security

Demand more #

I applaud CISA leadership speaking out aggressively at the mWISE Conference 2024 about the dismal state of software security (based on reporting in The Register, but it would be nice for www.cisa.gov to publish transcripts in order to ensure we are interpreting remarks with full context, given that the videos are paywalled).

While agreeing with the aspirations and good intentions, behind the words I worry about how CISA views the problem. It’s very bold, yet I would say it stops short of being actionable.

What follows are a few quotes from the article on the speech with my observations:

“Why does software require so many urgent patches?”

“The truth is: We need to demand more of technology vendors.”

“Despite a multi-billion-dollar cyber security industry, we still have a multi-trillion-dollar software quality issue leading to a multi-trillion-dollar global cyber crime issue.”

“We don’t need more security products – we need more secure products.”

In conclusion, I completely agree that it would be awesome if the changes CISA seeks ever came to pass, but I don’t see how we get from here to there. To put the situation in blunt economic terms, today the costs of security risk are an externality for software makers that customers are forced to accept. Externalities (meaning, in industrial terms, dumping waste into the river instead of designing a zero-emissions factory) are always grossly inefficient in overall cost, but do serve to save costs at the source, hence the aforementioned “multi-trillion-dollar global cyber crime issue”.

Operating system companies own the platforms so they call the shots, and doing what CISA wants would mean incurring massive red ink with only a vision of a better world in return (CISA isn’t suggesting software should cost more if we ever got better security). The rest of the industry is downstream of the platforms and it’s very questionable that they can make much of a dent in the problem unless the operating systems change first (because you can’t build secure apps on top of an operating system that isn’t designed with that as a priority, just as a stock car is never going to win a Formula 1 race).

The only alternative would be an equally massive effort to design and build a competitive operating system from scratch with security as top priority, and the prospects of a lucrative market for such a hypothetical product are at best speculative (especially compared to the very profitable and stable status quo).

So how do we make progress on security? I see three broad approaches:

Which road ahead should we take, any other ideas, or just stick with the status quo?

∴ ∴ ∴ ∴