Incoming message mess

#security

July 30, 2024 — When will we address the unacceptable status quo of scam phone calls, SMS text, and email?

Today I got a cold call from someone purporting to represent my health insurer (I don’t actually doubt they do, but it would be gullible to take the word of a stranger) and they started the conversation demanding personal information “for security purposes”. I didn’t watch Black Mirror but at times I feel like I’m living in an episode. This is a large corporation failing to see what’s wrong with that — for starters, the FCC tells consumers, “Don’t answer calls from unknown numbers. Never give out personal information in response to unexpected calls…” The caller ID number can be spoofed by scammers, the FCC also tells us.

Sadder still, that I’m likely an outlier in making a fuss and most people comply so countless of these calls work day in and day out so nothing changes. I get how from their perspective they are the good guys doing this, but it isn’t that hard to step into the customer’s shoes and consider how these calls are received.

Corporations who do this, or outsource it, and doing society a huge disservice in normalizing poor security practice. They demand personal information for their “security purposes” but don’t care one whit about the customer’s security. Our communication systems have been so thoroughly manipulated and abused for dishonest monetization that incoming messages of any form — phone calls, email, SMS texts, you name it — are all essentially unsafe to respond to. “Don’t call us, we’ll call you” is our last resort. The FCC spoofing advisory even says that pressing a number on the keypad can indicate you are a potential “mark” for future calls, and that recording your voice saying “Yes” and “No” can be used to fraudulently create evidence you agreed to something over the phone.

Instead of attempting to train all citizens to be suspicious of all incoming calls, I suggest we fix the system that enables countless opportunities for scams. The communications industry has shirked their responsibility to steward a secure system, and no doubt due to intense lobbying our lawmakers have failed to regulate it properly so we can trust it. Securing our systems does incur a cost, just as reaching out to customers securely would for corporations (compared to cold calling), but investing in better infrastructure yields all kinds of long-term benefits lifting all boats.

Dumping the burden on the poor consumer to fend off all scammers is so much easier. Insecure systems always give advantages to the rich (who can afford to protect themselves with assistants) and the unscrupulous willing to bend the rules for their own profit, with the honest trusting (even gullible) citizen at a disadvantage every time.

Reading that FCC guidance (first link above) is downright depressing. Maybe this is the best advice they can offer given the hostile reality of our phone and internet infrastructure and the levels of sophisticated scamming out there, but every point they suggest screams for better answers — and I don’t think any of this is technically difficult to solve if we only committed to it.

We could have a “blue check mark” (the classic meaning from the heyday of Twitter, not X that just charges for it) caller ID that was reliable. We could have a national register of trustworthy companies and enterprises, with stated specific purposes they do place phone calls, all integrated into our phones as standard. It’s nice that our phones allow us to report spam phone calls but we don’t get to see what happens from there: status of our complaint, how many others reported that number, if any action was taken, statistics for our state and the country. And this would just be a start, surely many innovative mitigations are possible.

I have no doubt most Americans are already annoyed and fed up, so it looks like a political failure. I don’t know how to fix that; all I can think of is a strike, let’s all just stop answering the phone unless we know who’s calling and expect their call (I always welcome and expect calls from family and friends). Some legit calls will get missed, but they can send us a letter. It’s a small sacrifice, but any protest always is, and I cannot remember ever getting an urgent unexpected call from a stranger that was very helpful. I hope this informal analysis makes clear that it isn’t a technical challenge and we don’t have to live with this mess any longer than we choose to by inaction.